Articles 
About 
Advertise 
Events 
Reports 
Events 
Newsletter 
Devices
Distribution
Marketing
Social
Startups
Systems
Travel sectors
Regions
Airbnb admits rogue sales team used Craigslist for stealthy property drive
Apartment rental service Airbnb has confirmed salespeople made unsolicited approaches to property owners on classified listings service Craigslist.
An unknown number of salespeople contracted to the company, but said to be working remotely, used Craigslist to attract new customers to Airbnb by pretending to be ordinary punters talking up the benefits of the service.
The tactic came to light in a blog post by Dave Gooden explaining how he created a number of anonymous accounts on Craigslist and was subsequently approached by a number individuals raving about Airbnb and urging him to list his property with the site.
At no point did the individuals identify themselves as employees or contractors of Airbnb. Gooden’s suspicions were raised when he received identical approaches each time.
Airbnb, one of the most talked about travel startups for years, has now admitted that contractors used the tactic to find new property owners, although it has today come out strongly against the process after claiming it has only recently come to its attention.
An official says:
“This is not a tactic we condone or endorse, and it is our policy to forbid such actions.”
Its own investigation has confirmed that no automated process or data harvesting was used but it has no indication as to how widespread the tactic became.
“We did have remote sales people that we contracted to acquire listings through person-to-person sales, but their efforts were largely ineffective.”
Acknowledging the existence of the controversial (“black hat”, says Gooden) marketing tactic comes as the spotlight has beamed even brighter on Airbnb in recent weeks.
The company is rumoured (officials consistent with “no comments” all week) to be negotiating a mammoth $100 million+ funding round, a figure which some say would value the business at an eye-watering $1 billion.
Airbnb does not publish the number of properties featured on the service but has confirmed today that it currently has around 110,000 listed – around half of those on rival rental service HomeAway.
About the Writer :: Kevin May
Kevin May is a senior editor and one of the co-founders at Tnooz. He was previously editor of UK-based magazine Travolution and web editor of Media Week UK from 2003 to 2005.
He has worked in regional newspapers (Essex Enquirer) and started his career in journalism at the Police Gazette at New Scotland Yard in London. He has a degree in criminology, a postgraduate diploma in magazine journalism and will be publishing his first book - a biography about electronic band, Depeche Mode - soon.
bob hope
AirBnB is STILL polluting craigslist listings through various ILLEGAL tactics. They should be sued by craigslist.
They will post ads which are designed to frustrate, later the listings get emails from AirBnB. Why craiglist hasn’t done anything is a mystery.
Kenneth Thomas
Who cares? They used available data to approach growing a potential business. If they didn’t “harvest ” and build a database, they should have. Not identifying is a little astroturfish, but c’mon. Others would say it was a slick approach.
And AirBNB is *so* much better than CL.
Nothing to see here, except a mountain being made from a molehill.
Zaarly Employee Tries to Poach Craigslist Advertiser - World Bad News : World Bad News
[…] people posting skill listings on Craigslist to emanate a inventory on Airbnb as well, according to Tnooz.” Entrepreneur David Gooden indeed valid a claims on his possess blog of programmed spamming and […]
Zaarly employee tries to poach Craigslist advertiser | VentureBeat
[…] people posting property listings on Craigslist to create a listing on Airbnb as well, according to Tnooz.” Entrepreneur David Gooden actually proved the claims on his own blog of automated spamming […]
Toni
Who cares, Airbnb is an awesome service and why not tell others about it. I do. Craigslist is doing pretty well and so I’m sure they didn’t feel a thing.
Social Spam Required by Bing & Google | Living Websites
[…] Sure there will be some edge case successes (like luxury brands maintaining their positions), but success from newer & smaller players will be uncommon exceptions (often operating outside the terms of service). […]
Airbnb captures $112M funding round, wants global domination | Tnooz
[…] admitted in June 2011 that a rogue group of contract sales people had used Craigslist to make unsolicited approaches to owners to persuade them to sign up to the […]
Webmaster Tricks And Tips » Social Spam Required by Bing & Google
[…] Sure there will be some edge case successes (like luxury brands maintaining their positions), but success from newer & smaller players will be uncommon exceptions (often operating outside the terms of service). […]
Social Spam Required by Bing & Google « UpToDateForFun
[…] Sure there will be some edge case successes (like luxury brands maintaining their positions), but success from newer & smaller players will be uncommon exceptions (often operating outside the terms of service). […]
Social Spam Required by Bing & Google | Juice My Blog
[…] Sure there will be some edge case successes (like luxury brands maintaining their positions), but success from newer & smaller players will be uncommon exceptions (often operating outside the terms of service). […]
Social Spam Required by Bing & Google « Seo « Artificial Intelligence SEO
[…] Sure there will be some edge case successes (like luxury brands maintaining their positions), but success from newer & smaller players will be uncommon exceptions (often operating outside the terms of service). […]
Mohammed almuaini » How AirBnB stole the startup spotlight
[…] AirBnB, and that those on Craiglist encourage viewers to check them out on the alternative site. Tnooz reports that the social vacation rentals site has copped to the unsavory business tactic, saying […]
Episode 4: - Anpret
[…] AirBNB Exposed. Admits it. […]
Social Spam Required by Bing & Google « Designs By Brian
[…] Sure there will be some edge case successes (like luxury brands maintaining their positions), but success from newer & smaller players will be uncommon exceptions (often operating outside the terms of service). […]
Social Spam Required by Bing & Google | Aitir Google Lab
[…] Sure there will be some edge case successes (like luxury brands maintaining their positions), but success from newer & smaller players will be uncommon exceptions (often operating outside the terms of service). […]
Social Spam Required by Bing & Google | Mega Webster
[…] Sure there will be some edge case successes (like luxury brands maintaining their positions), but success from newer & smaller players will be uncommon exceptions (often operating outside the terms of service). […]
#1 Building Sustainable Ventures « Exit Junkie
[…] 1. Systems – Don’t lie, don’t cheat in your business procedures and day-to-day activities. Yesterday, I was reading an article about how AirBnB just got $100 million on a $1 billion valuation. Impressive valuation for a company that not many people know. One blogger though, seemed to disagree with the numbers that AirBnB was putting out to its investors and sure enough presented a case against their business practices. (UPDATE – AirBnB admits Craigslist rogue sales practices) […]
Will Airbnb Ever Be “The Airbnb For X”? | Ebay shopping tips
[…] Airbnb seems to be the one that got away for many investors, who are now closely watching the roster of startups that are slowly disrupting certain sections of Craigslist (and in the case of Airbnb, doing this literally). […]
How AirBnB stole the startup spotlight (Digital Trends)
[…] AirBnB, and that those on Craiglist encourage viewers to check them out on the alternative site. Tnooz reports that the social vacation rentals site has copped to the unsavory business tactic, saying […]
How AirBnB stole the startup spotlight
[…] AirBnB, and that those on Craiglist encourage viewers to check them out on the alternative site. Tnooz reports that the social vacation rentals site has copped to the unsavory business tactic, saying […]
TechCrunch News - Will Airbnb Ever Be “The Airbnb For X”? | NixTimes Daily News
[…] Airbnb seems to be the one that got away for many investors, who are now closely watching the roster of startups that are slowly disrupting certain sections of Craigslist (and in the case of Airbnb, doing this literally). […]
Will Airbnb Ever Be “The Airbnb For X”? - MEDIA|TEKHIS | MEDIA|TEKHIS
[…] Airbnb seems to be the one that got away for many investors, who are now closely watching the roster of startups that are slowly disrupting certain sections of Craigslist (and in the case of Airbnb, doing this literally). […]
Will Airbnb Ever Be “The Airbnb For X”? | User Manual Guide
[…] Airbnb seems to be the one that got away for many investors, who are now closely watching the roster of startups that are slowly disrupting certain sections of Craigslist (and in the case of Airbnb, doing this literally). […]
Will Airbnb Ever Be “The Airbnb For X”? | MakeNoise : MakeNoise
[…] Airbnb seems to be the one that got away for many investors, who are now closely watching the roster of startups that are slowly disrupting certain sections of Craigslist (and in the case of Airbnb, doing this literally). […]
Best of Tnooz This Week - Black hatter, Orbitz jabber, Groupon hyper | Tnooz
[…] Airbnb admits rogue sales team used Craigslist for stealthy property drive […]
Sean O'
I’m with Dennis. I’m not buying the explanation.
Sean O'
Solid journalism. Nicely done.
Stuart
And just to clarify my last point I’m not suggesting AirBnb is the Second Coming…
Stuart
@Chris How exactly is it fraudulent? I mean I used to get the JHV knocking at my door promising all sorts of stuff, I didn’t ask who they were propping for (Just sent em packing) but same principle nah? If the punter doesn’t ask who you’re speaking for …
1 Billion Dollar Craiglist Spam Campaign » Money Machines Blog
[…] June 02, 2001] AirBnB now admits to using Craigslist spam. I wonder if they could now be sued by anyone who get an unsolicited email […]
Airbnb Admits It Farmed Craigslist, Blames Outside Salespeople | TechDiem.com
[…] (Via Tnooz) […]
Chris
@Stuart It’s fraud, deception for gain, and is not even close to using competitor’s keywords. It should be illegal.
Unfortunately it’s a common theme amongst many high growth startups, using fraudulent but technically legal strategies (e.g. fake listings, astroturf and deceptive marketing) to acquire mindshare quickly at the distributed expense of deceived customers and other more legitimate businesses.
dave
One billion for that piece of crap? LMAO
ryan
Is that what it takes to succeed? As a vacation rental owner, I hated their services. Very pushy and monitored my correspondance with potential renters to make sure I wasn’t using any services but theirs.
Tony C
I don’t believe the roque sales team story for a second. Remote sales people do not take it upon themselves (all at the same time) to create a process to send hundreds of thousands (or more) emails. This is bulls*t to make the story go away.
But don’t hold your breath if you expect anyone to care. No one cares because they’re making tons of money.
WazWoo
Do you blame them? Gotta use whats at your disposal!
bob
Ya… that’s complete bs. They absolutely knew about — and encouraged — this behavior. Craigslist should launch a clone and then sue them under CAN SPAM.
Dennis Schaal
I’m not necessarily buying the “rogue” explanation. Notice that Airbnb says it had contracted salespeople engaged “to acquire listings through person-to-person sales…”
I mean, what were they contracted to do? Ring people’s doorbells?
Sam Daams
Reminds me a lot of how a certain flight meta search engine ended up with a ‘most downloaded’ iphone app.
Stuart
Dave’s writeup is interesting, but would hardly paint it in the black hat light he is — and he does run a competing business. Yes the floosies should have announced themselves as spruiking for Airbnb, but I’d put this at about the same level as competitors bidding on one another’s keywords – ie preferable if it didn’t happen but as it does, yawn.