Expedia removes American Airlines fares, new twist on Orbitz row

Expedia has removed fares from American Airlines in its search results in an unprecedented show of support for rival online travel agency Orbitz.

expedia aa depref

Expedia confirmed that as of yesterday (Thurs 22 December) it had “adjusted” the way the carrier’s fares are displayed across its sites – meaning the carrier now features at the far end of its list of available airlines and prices will not be shown, replaced with a link to a results page elsewhere on the site.

In essence, American is a “de-preferenced” airline on Expedia.

An official says the move was made for two reasons: in the light of AA’s decision to prevent Orbitz from selling the carrier’s inventory and “possible disruption” in Expedia’s ability to sell tickets from American Airlines when its contract expires.

Expedia’s existing agreement with American Airlines is due to run out Dec. 31.

In a strongly worded statement, in which Expedia also says the now infamous Direct-Connect system is “fundamentally bad for travelers”, the official adds:

“American Airlines has shown it only intends to do business with travel agencies through a new model that is anti-consumer and anti-choice.

“We believe American Airlines’ proposed direct connect model will result in higher costs and reduced transparency for consumers, making it difficult to compare AA ticket prices and options with offerings by other airlines.

“American Airlines’ direct connect model is of questionable, if any, benefit to travelers, costly to build and maintain and would compromise travel agents’ ability to provide travelers with the best selection.”

American Airlines has hit back with a strongly worded statement.

The carrier is essentially either no longer listed at all (its own doing) or seeing its fares way down the pecking order (by virtue of Expedia’s latest action) for visitors on two of the biggest online travel agencies in the US.

The question now is whether the carrier – and, indeed, the OTAs – can live without one another commercially and if consumers will cry foul.

PhoCusWright‘s senior research director, Douglas Quinby, says:

“Expedia is calling American’s hand, but I am not so sure the airline is bluffing. The current supply/demand dynamics, with strong corporate demand and still soft leisure demand, favor airlines. What is clear, we’ve gone from brinkmanship to all out warfare. The only question is, who’s next, and when?”

Meanwhile, according to Forrester‘s top travel analyst, Henry Hartveldt, Orbitz drives around $800 million in sales to American Airlines every year – this is not a figure to be sniffed at, yet American Airlines clearly believes its actions earlier this week and the wider Direct-Connect issue are worth doing.

Sabre, which was quick to lend its support to Travelport and Orbitz earlier this week, has issued its own statement:

“Sabre has seen the action taken by Expedia and we fully support Expedia taking steps to protect its customers’ interests and make clear its preference to continue using the proven system that enables it to efficiently and cost-effectively serve its customers.”

Sabre-owned Travelocity has not got involved as yet.

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInEmail to someone
 
 
Kevin May

About the Writer :: Kevin May

Kevin May was a co-founder and member of the editorial team from September 2009 to June 2017.

 

Comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. US government delivers transparent warning to GDSs and online travel agencies | Tnooz

    […] decision to bias American Airlines’ flights in the GDS in early January 2011 and Expedia’s similar action on its websites in December 2010, before removing American’s flights altogether in a contract dispute the next month, prompted […]

     
  2. Amadeus reviewing airline deals, hits out at Direct-Connect model | Tnooz

    […] also kept quiet when Expedia retaliated a few days later and first de-preferenced AA fares and then axed them […]

     
  3. Behind Expedia action against American Airlines and supply chain wrath | Tnooz

    […] in regarding the American-Expedia contract negotiations, which led to the online travel agency de-preferencing the airline’s flights and fares Dec. 22 and removing them altogether from Expedia Inc.’s leisure websites globally on Jan. 1, […]

     
  4. Expedia suspends American Airlines flights | Tnooz

    […] Related posts:Expedia removes American Airlines fares, new twist on Orbitz row […]

     
  5. American Airlines says sales up despite agency war, others very sceptical | Tnooz

    […] seven days after Expedia removed American Airlines’s fares from search results, in part supporting Orbitz and also the agency-GDS distribution model, airline executives are […]

     
  6. 10 Things That Caught My Eye: Week of 12-20-10 | Software Industry Insights

    […] Expedia puts a lump of coal in AA’s stocking. And then it just got a little sad when American tried to play the victim, when Expedia employed a Bush/Cheney-doctrine like move with a pre-emptive strike, rather than waiting for AA to turn their attentions to them. American may try to guide prospective flyers to Priceline and Kayak as alternatives, but given that Priceline doesn’t sell a lot of air travel and Kayak doesn’t actually take bookings, I’m not sure how well that’s going to turn out…especially if the prospective traveler has to go to AA.com to learn they should go to Kayak or Priceline in the first place. […]

     
  7. How can one travel first-class between cities in Mexico DF? | world travel tours

    […] Expedia removes American Airlines fares, new twist on Orbitz row … […]

     
  8. American Airlines touts Kayak, Priceline as favored online travel websites | Tnooz

    […] The two sides were believed to be talking earlier this week — unitl Expedia abruptly de-preferenced American Airlines’ flights. […]

     
  9. Dennis Schaal

    Dennis Schaal

    Robert: Expedia’s policy so far does not apply to Egencia. So for Expedia’s corporate customers nothing is being taken away — for now.

    However, look for things to heat up even further because the AA-Expedia contract runs out in a few days…. Dec. 31.

    Kevin Mitchell: Yes, it is more than moral support on Expedia’s part. Expedia and AA are locked in a contract battle, as well.

     
  10. Top Tnooz this week - American fall-out and Predictions 2011 | Tnooz

    […] Expedia removes American Airlines fares, new twist on Orbitz row […]

     
  11. Timothy O'Neil-Dunne

    Today was one of those days when the world changes. For better or worse. Analysis next year will in my view demonstrate this was the seminal moment when indeed things changed.

    Perhaps one perspective is to consider that there is a peeling back of the onion skin. The web is about transparency – as we see here at TNooz – we can comment freely – and this is part of the fabric of today’s business and social world.

    The true cost of the airline ticket has morphed from a homogeneous single bundled (and commoditized) price to a more transparent view of the components that make up the airline ticket. Obviously that makes it harder from the consumer’s point of view to shop. But we all need to get over that. The Genie was let out of the bottle a long time ago and its ain’t going back. From today onwards that now includes the cost of distribution. This transparency allows the product owner and the seller to attach a clearer monetary value to its brand – good or bad. Further as this dispute has demonstrated the brand proposition of the intermediary now becomes clear.

    In my view Expedia’s move is very ballsy but I question whether it was smart. In my view they have traded demonstrating their power for their value as an unbiased intermediary. Sadly if Expedia is not able to offer a level playing field to its customers and ends up in dispute with its supply chain then it must accept that its value proposition has changed. In my judgment that change is irrevocable – another genie out of the bottle that isn’t going back. The preemptive action by Expedia today demonstrates how they feel. Expedia can no longer position itself as the champion of unbiased neutral intermediary, which to the consumer is an essential part of its proposition. It becomes clear that the company and its brand have optimized its product offerings to its own selfish ends and now ‘games’ the customer as much as the suppliers can do through their own direct channels such as their websites.

    Thus now the Expedia Company through its own actions has removed the (admittedly thinly veiled) veneer of neutrality from not only the Expedia brand but also its family of brands from Hotwire to TripAdvisor.

    The reaction by the intermediaries and organizations who have thrown more than vocal support of support of Orbitz in its dispute with AA, in my view – may have shot themselves in the foot. The consumer will now realize that the intermediary channels as a class are not acting in the best interests of the consumer. As I noted in my 2011 predictions the concept of value finding will now emerge. For those Intermediaries who support the Orbitz and its 48% owner Travelport their position becomes tainted in my opinion. Value Finding will definitely be part of the Social Web. Thus they have forfeited their ability to be an arbiter of customer value which has very broad and deep long lasting implications.

    Unlike in media where there is a definitive traditional separation between publishing and editorial content, in travel etailing, the line for an unbiased intermediary has been crossed. Thus anyone owning an outlet will now find it harder to maintain some semblance of neutrality and consumer advocacy.

    It gives a whole new meaning (not necessarily good) to Expedia’s current tag line – where you book matters.

    Cheers

     
    • Scott Gillespie

      So how is Expedia’s move to “de=preference” AA that much different from Expedia not offering Southwest’s fares? Seems one is by the airline’s choice, the other by the OTA’s, yet both have the same consequences for the consumer.

       
  12. Scott Gillespie

    So what will Egencia, Expedia’s corporate booking division, do with its AA inventory? Can’t quite see them telling their corporate accounts “Sorry, you’ll have to work harder to book AA through us now, or call your traditional TMC.”

     
    • RobertKCole

      Excellent point Scott – The corporate market segment is what made Expedia back off with InterContinental Hotels in 2004 when the battle for hotel pricing control occurred and InterContinental cut off Expedia.

      I have to think the Orbitz for Business customers are not very happy. Wondering how it will play out for Egencia – corporate accounts don’t like being told something is being taken away – especially if it is still available through competitors…

       
  13. Is Sabre biasing American Airlines flights for employee travel? | Tnooz

    […] Travelport GDS added a surcharge on certain American Airlines flights and Expedia has made finding American Airlines fares a laborious task in the wake of the airline’s withdrawal from Orbitz, Sabre several days ago began making it […]

     
  14. RobertKCole

    Obvious titles if this was a movie: “The Empire Strikes Back” or “Revenge of the Nerds.”

    The only problem is that it is hard to tell who is playing the role of the Empire and who are the Nerds….

    Truly, Only one definitive solution…

    Cage Match. The winner gets a belt and the ability to boast about world domination.

     
  15. American Airlines slams Expedia for fare display snub | Tnooz

    […] shock decision by Expedia, revealed earlier today, to essentially strip AA’s fares out of the results, leaving it with just a name and link […]

     
  16. when to be pissed off at an airline « Manifest Density

    […] raw deal in the media. I find it astounding that any reporter could be so credulous as to write this story. Expedia’s offering moral support to Orbitz? Right. […]

     
    • Kevin Mitchell

      The reporter did not say or imply, in my reading, “moral” support. “Expedia has removed fares from American Airlines in its search results in an unprecedented show of support for rival online travel agency Orbitz,” is merely a statement of fact. Like many other observers and airline participants, Expedia likely sees alignment of interests among consumers, competitor Orbitz and its own business interests.

       
  17. Jonathan Alford

    It seems we will need FairAirline, FairGDS, and FairOTA groups now as well. The question is who would be in what group?

     
    • Kevin May

      Kevin May

      @jonathan – FairTravel perhaps? 😉

       
      • Jonathan Alford

        @kevin – good one. Hopefully that would be the overall goal, yes? Perhaps FairTravel could be the intersection in the Venn diagram where each group promotes its alignment toward consumer interests – though how each defines that would be interesting given the commentary going on…

        Fascinating skirmish going on in the business where the retailers compete directly with their suppliers…

         
  18. Tweets that mention Expedia removes fares from American Airlines in support of Orbitz | Tnooz -- Topsy.com

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Dennis Schaal, Alex Bainbridge, Brian Eng, James Craven and others. James Craven said: RT @kevinlukemay: BREAKING: Expedia removes American #Airline s fares in support of Orbitz http://bit.ly/gOqQ9q [Tnooz] #OTA […]

     
  19. AA "de-preferenced" by Expedia - FlyerTalk Forums

    […] on Orbitz effective today (12/21/10)), Expedia has "de-preferenced" AA according to this article. AA now appears at the far end of its list of available airlines and prices will not be shown, […]

     
 
 

Newsletter Subscription

Please subscribe now to Tnooz’s FREE daily newsletter.

This lively package of news and information from Tnooz’s web site provides a convenient digest of what’s happening in technology that drives the global travel, tourism and hospitality market.

  • Cancel